In Capitol Records v. Foster, in federal court in Oklahoma, a case against a mother — whose only connection to the alleged filesharing was that she was the person who paid for the internet access — has been dismissed with prejudice. Faced with the mother’s motion for leave to file a summary judgment motion dismissing the case against her, and awarding her attorneys fees, the RIAA made its own motion for permission to withdraw its case. The Court granted the motion and let the RIAA drop its case. The Court went on to hold that the defendant, Ms. Foster, is the ‘prevailing party’ under the Copyright Act and is therefore eligible for an award of attorneys fees. The link is to a pdf of the order. More …
“With prejudice” means they can not sue her on the same causes in their complaint. “Without prejudice” means they can re-file the same case anytime. The opposite of when it first meets the ear.